Out of Lane

Role

There are cases where the ego vehicle footprint goes out of the driving lane, for example when taking a narrow turn with a large vehicle. The out_of_lane module adds deceleration and stop points to the ego trajectory in order to prevent collisions from occurring in these out of lane cases.

Activation

This module is activated if the launch parameter launch_out_of_lane_module is set to true.

Inner-workings / Algorithms

This module calculates if out of lane collisions occur and insert stop point before the collisions if necessary.

The algorithm assumes the input ego trajectory contains accurate time_from_start values in order to calculate accurate time to collisions with the predicted objects.

Next we explain the inner-workings of the module in more details.

1. Ego trajectory footprints

In this first step, the ego footprint is projected at each trajectory point and its size is modified based on the ego.extra_..._offset parameters.

The length of the trajectory used for generating the footprints is limited by the max_arc_length parameter.

2. Other lanelets

In the second step, we calculate the lanelets where collisions should be avoided. We consider all lanelets around the ego vehicle that are not crossed by the trajectory linestring (sequence of trajectory points) or their preceding lanelets.

In the debug visualization, these other lanelets are shown as blue polygons.

3. Out of lane areas

Next, for each trajectory point, we create the corresponding out of lane areas by intersection the other lanelets (from step 2) with the trajectory point footprint (from step 1). Each area is associated with the lanelets overlapped by the area and with the corresponding ego trajectory point.

In the debug visualization, the out of lane area polygon is connected to the corresponding trajectory point by a line.

4. Predicted objects filtering

We filter objects and their predicted paths with the following conditions:

• ignore objects with a speed bellow the minimum_velocity parameter;
• ignore objects coming from behind the ego vehicle if parameter ignore_behind_ego is set to true;
• ignore predicted paths whose confidence value is bellow the predicted_path_min_confidence parameter;
• cut the points of predicted paths going beyond the stop line of a red traffic light if parameter cut_predicted_paths_beyond_red_lights is set to true.

cut_predicted_paths_beyond_red_lights = false	cut_predicted_paths_beyond_red_lights = true

In the debug visualization, the filtered predicted paths are shown in green and the stop lines of red traffic lights are shown in red.

5. Time to collisions

For each out of lane area, we calculate the times when a dynamic object will overlap the area based on its filtered predicted paths.

In the case where parameter mode is set to threshold and the calculated time is less than threshold.time_threshold parameter, then we decide to avoid the out of lane area.

In the case where parameter mode is set to ttc, we calculate the time to collision by comparing the predicted time of the object with the time_from_start field contained in the trajectory point. If the time to collision is bellow the ttc.threshold parameter value, we decide to avoid the out of lane area.

In the debug visualization, the ttc (in seconds) is displayed on top of its corresponding trajectory point. The color of the text is red if the collision should be avoided and green otherwise.

6. Calculate the stop or slowdown point

First, the minimum stopping distance of the ego vehicle is calculated based on the jerk and deceleration constraints set by the velocity smoother parameters.

We then search for the furthest pose along the trajectory where the ego footprint stays inside of the ego lane (calculate in step 2) and constraint the search to be between the minimum stopping distance and the 1st trajectory point with a collision to avoid (as determined in the previous step). The search is done by moving backward along the trajectory with a distance step set by the action.precision parameter.

We first do this search for a footprint expanded with the ego.extra_..._offset, action.longitudinal_distance_buffer and action.lateral_distance_buffer parameters. If no valid pose is found, we search again while only considering the extra offsets but without considering the distance buffers. If still no valid pose is found, we use the base ego footprint without any offset. In case no pose is found, we fallback to using the pose before the detected collision without caring if it is out of lane or not.

Whether it is decided to slow down or stop is determined by the distance between the ego vehicle and the trajectory point to avoid. If this distance is bellow the actions.slowdown.threshold, a velocity of actions.slowdown.velocity will be used. If the distance is bellow the actions.stop.threshold, a velocity of 0m/s will be used.

About stability of the stop/slowdown pose

As the input trajectory can change significantly between iterations, it is expected that the decisions of this module will also change. To make the decision more stable, a stop or slowdown pose is used for a minimum duration set by the action.min_duration parameter. If during that time a new pose closer to the ego vehicle is generated, then it replaces the previous one. Otherwise, the stop or slowdown pose will only be discarded after no out of lane collision is detection for the set duration.

Module Parameters

Parameter	Type	Description
mode	string	[-] mode used to consider a dynamic object. Candidates: threshold, intervals, ttc
skip_if_already_overlapping	bool	[-] if true, do not run this module when ego already overlaps another lane
max_arc_length	double	[m] maximum trajectory arc length that is checked for out_of_lane collisions

Parameter /threshold	Type	Description
time_threshold	double	[s] consider objects that will reach an overlap within this time

Parameter /ttc	Type	Description
threshold	double	[s] consider objects with an estimated time to collision bellow this value while ego is on the overlap

Parameter /objects	Type	Description
minimum_velocity	double	[m/s] ignore objects with a velocity lower than this value
predicted_path_min_confidence	double	[-] minimum confidence required for a predicted path to be considered
cut_predicted_paths_beyond_red_lights	bool	[-] if true, predicted paths are cut beyond the stop line of red traffic lights
ignore_behind_ego	bool	[-] if true, objects behind the ego vehicle are ignored

Parameter /action	Type	Description
precision	double	[m] precision when inserting a stop pose in the trajectory
longitudinal_distance_buffer	double	[m] safety distance buffer to keep in front of the ego vehicle
lateral_distance_buffer	double	[m] safety distance buffer to keep on the side of the ego vehicle
min_duration	double	[s] minimum duration needed before a decision can be canceled
slowdown.distance_threshold	double	[m] insert a slow down when closer than this distance from an overlap
slowdown.velocity	double	[m] slow down velocity
stop.distance_threshold	double	[m] insert a stop when closer than this distance from an overlap

Parameter /ego	Type	Description
extra_front_offset	double	[m] extra front distance to add to the ego footprint
extra_rear_offset	double	[m] extra rear distance to add to the ego footprint
extra_left_offset	double	[m] extra left distance to add to the ego footprint
extra_right_offset	double	[m] extra right distance to add to the ego footprint